Top-Performing Email Strategies from March

Discover which emails earned 258 clicks and why connection beats perfection in email marketing.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur.

How can affiliate links be used effectively in emails?

Opening: Incorporating affiliate links subtly within valuable content can generate income while providing value to subscribers.

Quote:

'A quick note about this email, it did include an affiliate link, and I knew the petite lawyer that was going to be having a sale later on in March. So of course, I earned some affiliate commission from people that went on to purchase later. So it was smart, but more than anything, I wanted to send them something that was really useful.'


Takeaway:
• Affiliate marketing can be integrated into emails by offering genuinely useful resources.
• Prioritize providing value; commissions are a secondary benefit.
• Transparent and helpful affiliate promotions build trust and can boost earnings.

What can you learn from underperforming emails?

Opening: Analyzing emails that didn't perform as expected provides valuable insights to improve future campaigns.

Quote:

'Now, not everything was perfect... So what did I learn in March? So here are a few things March really drove home for me... The email that looked great on the surface, but it didn't quite convert.'


Takeaway:
• Review underperforming emails to identify areas of improvement.
• Understanding why an email didn't convert helps refine content and strategy.
• Continuous learning from successes and failures enhances campaign performance.

How important is it to match email content to subscriber expectations?

Opening: Aligning your email content with what your subscribers expect ensures higher engagement and reduces unsubscribes.

Quote:

'I segmented my list, so I did exclude people that were already in a different funnel, so they weren't being bombarded with this email. This email was selectively sent to subscribers that were just getting my weekly content.'


Takeaway:
• List segmentation helps deliver relevant content to the right audience.
• Targeted emails improve open rates and engagement.
• Respecting subscriber preferences reduces unsubscribes.

How does audience engagement change when you reduce email frequency?

Opening: Reducing email frequency doesn't necessarily lead to audience forgetting about you; strategic communication keeps engagement high.

Quote:

'I sent fewer emails in March than I did in February, and my list still stayed warm and active. I wasn't forgotten. I wasn't ignored. I just showed up differently and it still worked.'


Takeaway:
• Quality over quantity: Fewer, more meaningful emails can maintain engagement.
• Audiences appreciate thoughtful communication over frequent messages.
• Adjusting frequency can prevent subscriber fatigue.

Why is balancing sales and nurture emails important?

Opening: Striking the right balance between sales and nurturing in your email campaigns is crucial for maintaining audience engagement and trust.

Quote:

'Now, I know this. I know this through and through, but I find that in the online business world, there is so much talk about sales sequences and promo plans... but honestly, the emails that performed best were the ones that asked for nothing.'


Takeaway:
• Overemphasis on sales can fatigue your audience; nurturing keeps them engaged.
• Providing value without always selling strengthens subscriber relationships.
• Balanced email strategies lead to better long-term performance.

What happens when a subject line doesn't match email content?

Opening: A compelling subject line needs to be backed up by equally compelling content and clear calls to action to maintain engagement.

Quote:

'So what I think happened here is this, the subject line was really strong. It created a lot of curiosity, but the body of the email didn't quite follow through... It's a great reminder that while subject lines matter, your content and calls to action need to deliver as well.'


Takeaway:
• Ensure your email content fulfills the promise of the subject line.
• Misaligned content can lead to low click-through rates despite high open rates.
• Clear and compelling calls to action are essential for conversions.

Why did a legal resource email perform well?

Opening: Sharing practical and helpful resources, even on less thrilling topics, can engage your audience effectively.

Quote:

'Legal stuff isn't usually the most thrilling topic, but this email was a quiet protector. I wasn't selling anything. I was simply pointing them to a resource that could help make sure their business was covered. And I think that's why it worked so well.'


Takeaway:
• Providing useful resources addresses your audience's real needs.
• Offering support without selling builds trust and credibility.
• Even less exciting topics can engage when they solve important problems.

How does email subject line clarity affect performance?

Opening: Crafting clear and exciting subject lines can significantly impact your email open rates and engagement.

Quote:

'Plus, the subject line was clear and exciting. The ultimate email marketing bundle is here. It matched the energy of the content inside the email perfectly.'


Takeaway:
• Clear and compelling subject lines increase open rates.
• Aligning the subject line with email content ensures subscriber expectations are met.
• Subject lines should reflect the value offered in the email.

Do generous, free offers improve email engagement?

Opening: Offering valuable, free resources to your audience without any pressure can significantly boost engagement and build trust.

Quote:

'The bundle was packed with trainings, templates, and tools from over 24 contributors, and because it was 100% free, the trust it built was instant.'


Takeaway:
• Providing high-value content for free can increase open and click-through rates.
• Free offers strengthen relationships with subscribers, leading to long-term loyalty.
• Generosity in your emails encourages positive responses and higher engagement.

How can nurturing emails boost engagement?

Opening: Nurturing your email list instead of constantly selling can significantly enhance engagement and build stronger relationships with your audience.

Quote:

'March was the exhale. There were no launches, no doors closing, no intense promo periods. Instead, I shifted my energy into nurture mode. I wanted to give back, create connection, and just support my people without asking for anything in return.'


Takeaway:
• Nurturing emails that offer value without expecting immediate returns can deepen audience trust.
• Focusing on building relationships keeps your list warm and active even when not actively selling.
• Balancing generosity with strategy leads to better long-term results.

Episode Info:

Title:
My Best Performing Emails in March [Ep 184]
Episode Link:
Keywords:
email marketing, open rates, engagement
Episode Air Date:
April 1, 2025

Podcast info:

Show Name:
The Email Growth Show
Author:
Kylie Kelly
Owner:
Kylie Kelly
Category:
Marketing

More summaries from this podcast:

Personalizing Email Templates with Liz Wilcox [Ep 165]

-
How to start with email marketing today?
-
Should you worry about mistakes in emails?
-
What is a super signature?
-
How to use email replies to boost sales?
-
Why do people buy when they are ready?
View summary

EFT Tapping: Recharge Goals with Jacqui Acree

-
Why acknowledge emotions in marketing?
-
How to use tapping to enhance marketing?
-
Why embrace the cyclical nature of marketing?
-
How to set realistic marketing expectations?
-
Is perfectionism blocking your marketing success?
View summary