Turning Followers Into Paying Members

Emma Walker learns to convert her 1M+ followers into paying members with smart promotions and strategic content shifts.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur.

The importance of welcome sequences

A well-crafted welcome sequence can nurture leads effectively.

"They go to the, they, they, you give them a URL, they go to the URL... They opt in, what happens next... You've got a welcome sequence, you've got a reminder of it."

Takeaway:
  • Use welcome sequences to introduce new subscribers to your offerings.
  • Remind subscribers of your offers during this period.
  • Nurture leads by providing value and building relationships.

Collecting additional data carefully

Adding fields to opt-in forms can improve segmentation but may reduce sign-ups.

"I found that when I add in like give us your phone number... our lead numbers actually drops a lot... adding some friction really can work... having a drop down that they can choose from... is great."

Takeaway:
  • Balance data collection with user experience.
  • Use optional dropdowns to gather useful segmentation data.
  • Avoid adding too much friction to the sign-up process.

Overcoming the guilt of selling

Embracing promotion as beneficial to both you and your audience is crucial.

"I think the first part is when you've got maximum eyeballs... put promo into that... You're currently investing an hour in... you want to get a return... every single week."

Takeaway:
  • Recognize that selling helps sustain your business.
  • Your offers provide value to your audience.
  • Integrating sales helps you continue providing free content.

Including clear calls to action

Not providing direct links can hinder conversions.

"What's really interesting... is the amount of people who've replied and said, Hey, tell me about this hub thing you mentioned casually in the newsletter but didn't link to... How many people would have clicked the link and just bought the damn thing?"

Takeaway:
  • Always include clear links when mentioning offers.
  • Make it easy for subscribers to take action.
  • You may lose potential sales by omitting calls to action.

Segmenting your email list effectively

Understanding your audience allows for better targeting and messaging.

"I realized that a lot of people who join my membership are teachers... So I've now... adding a little drop down menu so that they can select whether they're a learner or a teacher."

Takeaway:
  • Collect relevant information to segment your audience.
  • Customize messaging to different segments for better engagement.
  • Adding minimal friction can improve list quality without reducing sign-ups.

Using bonuses to encourage action

Offering bonuses can provide a compelling reason for subscribers to act now.

"What you could do when you, when you're looking at your promotion plan for the month, one, you're gonna have a reason to join for at least one week, which is gonna be the topic that you're gonna be teaching... Just give me, give people a little reason."

Takeaway:
  • Offer time-sensitive bonuses to incentivize action.
  • Creating urgency encourages subscribers to act promptly.
  • Regularly update bonuses to maintain interest.

Testing different promotional placements

Experimenting with ad-style and article-style promotions can reset readers' attention.

"I would test whether you make it look like an ad and like really like be like, this is a bloody ad, it is sponsored by this thing... And then try doing some that look like an article... So I would do both types of that, definitely."

Takeaway:
  • Test different formats for promotional content in emails.
  • Alternate between ad-style and article-style to capture interest.
  • Tracking results helps optimize for better engagement.

Using PS in emails for promotion

Including a PS in your emails can effectively highlight your offers.

"I was also thinking of testing out, uh, the PS. So, I, cause I found that, uh, one, a lot of people use like PS and then they add like something really important, uh, in, in the PS, uh, at the very bottom. And I've also tested it as well and found a lot of people click the link."

Takeaway:
  • Use a PS section to draw attention to your promotions.
  • Readers often notice and click links in the PS.
  • This technique can increase engagement and conversions.

Should you separate promo and value emails?

Many marketers struggle with balancing promotional content and value in their emails.

"I think it's because in my head I've always separated. Um, value emails and promo emails. Like, in, in my brain, I see it as like, this is a value email. Therefore, I cannot sell you anything. It must only be education and value."

Takeaway:
  • Separating promotional and value emails might limit sales opportunities.
  • Integrating promotions can provide value and encourage action.
  • Changing this mindset can improve email marketing performance.

Combining promotions and value emails

Combining promotional content with value in emails can greatly enhance engagement and conversions.

"So here's an idea. In your newsletter, which is content heavy, you can include promotion bits. Make it the second or third segment down. Not too far down. Maybe end with it as well. I would do it in two places."

Takeaway:
  • Integrate promotional content within value emails to maximize exposure.
  • Place promotions strategically within the email to capture more attention.
  • This approach can lead to higher conversions without alienating your audience.

Episode Info:

Title:
Consulting Session: How Can A Membership Site Owner with 1 Million Followers Turn Her Content Into Sales?
Episode Link:
Keywords:
membership, content marketing, audience conversion
Episode Air Date:
January 27, 2025

Podcast info:

Show Name:
The Email Marketing Show
Author:
Email Marketing Heroes
Owner:
Email Marketing Heroes
Category:
Business, Marketing

More summaries from this podcast:

Email Copy That Sells Without Being Pushy

-
How do emotions affect open rates?
-
How to boost open rates?
-
Should you ditch clichéd phrases?
-
What is an email's true purpose?
-
How to simplify customer actions?
View summary

One-Word Emails: Liz Wilcox's $600k Strategy

-
Can low-ticket offers be profitable?
-
How to use social proof in emails?
-
Focus on 'from' line or subject line?
-
How did Liz achieve a 100% conversion?
-
How can batching emails help you?
View summary