Cold Email Makeover: Boost Response Rates

Jeremy and Jack analyze a cold email to reduce tech churn. Learn key strategies to improve engagement and get better responses.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur.

The importance of explaining your secret sauce

Prospects need to understand how you can help them uniquely.

“So don't do that... It's more important to convince me that you can do this... Tell them your secret sauce.”

Takeaway:
  • Be transparent about how your solution works.
  • Provide insights into your unique approach.
  • Build trust by sharing valuable information.

Using emotional appeal over rational statistics

Emotional connection often trumps logical arguments in emails.

“One child going to bed hungry is a tragedy. 1 million children going to bed hungry is a statistic.”

Takeaway:
  • Leverage emotional storytelling to connect with your audience.
  • Humanize your message to make it more impactful.
  • Use stories to illustrate your point instead of relying solely on data.

Making your message recipient-focused

Centering your message on the recipient increases engagement.

“It's more important to convince me that you can do this... You're making a mistake, dude... That's how much it cost you.”

Takeaway:
  • Focus on how you can solve the recipient's problem.
  • Avoid language that blames or criticizes the recipient.
  • Offer constructive insights rather than pointing out faults.

The negative impact of overusing statistics

Too many stats can make your message impersonal.

“As soon as you do the stats, people become less empathic and then there's this less of a connection. And so why would you want that?”

Takeaway:
  • Balance data with relatable content to maintain engagement.
  • Use statistics sparingly and only when they enhance your message.
  • Remember that stories often resonate more than numbers.

Enhancing your email signature for credibility

Your email signature can be a powerful tool to build trust.

“I would suggest other things as well... build on you... and the number of clients you served... So for you specifically, I definitely build on you... maybe not a link but like a thing like, you know, it would be like .com you know, kicking us since 2013...”

Takeaway:
  • Include elements in your signature that establish authority.
  • Use social proof like client numbers or years in business.
  • Avoid clutter; focus on information that enhances credibility.

Providing a clear value proposition in emails

A clear explanation of how you can help is crucial.

“It is more important to convince me that you can do this and I will connect the dots... The magic in this is how they're able to reduce employee churn. I don't know how you do it.”

Takeaway:
  • Clearly explain how your product or service provides value.
  • Don't expect prospects to infer benefits without proper explanation.
  • Highlight the unique aspects of your solution.

The importance of personalization in cold emails

Personalization can significantly improve the effectiveness of your emails.

“I don't hate that they said how many open positions but it's not enough of a sentence... Let's see, Jeremy, given, you know, there's... don't say over 12 just say like, you know, given there's 12 open positions on your job portal, you know, right now we can connect this.”

Takeaway:
  • Use specific details to show you've researched your prospect.
  • Tailor your message to address their unique situation.
  • Small adjustments can make your email feel more personal and relevant.

How to avoid patronizing your prospects in emails

Coming across as condescending can deter potential customers.

“Don't do that. Don't teach your people that you want to sell to something that's the wrong... you know, sit down and learn something, write this down... You're just telling me I'm doing it way wrong, and you're telling me something that I know.”

Takeaway:
  • Address your prospects respectfully, acknowledging their expertise.
  • Avoid making assumptions about their current performance.
  • Focus on offering help rather than pointing out their mistakes.

Why statistics may weaken your email's emotional impact

Relying on statistics in your email might not create the connection you hope for.

“There is a study that... in donation, like you could say two story, you could say like, oh Polio Lily who grew up, whatever, like it's an emotional story and then lots of 1 million children. Exactly. You do the stats and it's just like as soon as you do the stats, people become less emphatic and then there's this less of a connection.”

Takeaway:
  • Using statistics can reduce empathy and weaken emotional connection.
  • Personal stories may be more effective than numbers in engaging your audience.
  • Consider balancing stats with emotional appeal to enhance impact.

How to choose the right subject line?

Crafting the perfect subject line can make or break your email campaign.

“I hate it. I hate it. Like everyone hates math anyway. I'm the only geek in this town. Just, no, no, it's not about that. It's, it's about this... Do the math and the rest of this smells like, isn't it obvious that you'd save so much money this way? You're clearly doing it wrong 300 grand.”

Takeaway:
  • Don’t use subject lines that might come off as condescending or patronizing.
  • Choose subject lines that are relevant and engaging to your audience.
  • Avoid subject lines that could make recipients defensive or uninterested.

Episode Info:

Title:
#382 - Watch us Fix a Cold Email Template in 10 Minutes
Episode Link:
Keywords:
Cold Emails, Engagement, Response Rates
Episode Air Date:
November 12, 2024

Podcast info:

Show Name:
Cold Email Outreach
Author:
Jeremy Chatelaine and Jack Reamer
Owner:
Jeremy Chatelaine
Category:
Business - Marketing

More summaries from this podcast:

Live Teardown: Enhance Your Cold Emails

-
How can feedback sessions improve your email campaigns?
-
How can scrapers improve your data quality?
-
What are the challenges with relying on third-party data providers?
-
How to create clear and thoughtful call-to-actions in emails?
-
Why is personalization important in cold emails?
View summary

Secrets Behind LinkedIn Super Connectors

-
How can you improve your own LinkedIn headline?
-
What words are most common in LinkedIn headlines?
-
Do you need to be famous to become a LinkedIn super connector?
-
Can social proof in your headline backfire?
-
What separators should you use in your LinkedIn headline?
View summary